|
U.S. Housing Market is Cracking. How Bad is it? Mike Turner | Nov 8, 2026 The numbers are sitting right there. If I were a news outlet, a podcast host, or a YouTuber who needed your click, here is how I could have used them:
"Foreclosures are up 21%. Homes in the foreclosure process, up 37% in a year, the highest since before the pandemic."
"Homes for sale in Austin, Denver and Nashville are more than 50% above normal. Seattle just posted the biggest price drop in the country."
"New homes are now selling for LESS than existing homes. That has not happened in 50 years. Builders are sitting on 111,000 houses nobody will buy."
"Pending home sales just hit the lowest level ever recorded, lower than the Covid lockdown. Prices just turned negative. This is how 2008 started."
Every one of those numbers is real. Strung together like that, they would have gotten record attention, because that is how most of what we read and listen to is built. Fear gets clicks, gets shared, and gets widely consumed. Fear also causes us to make poor, emotional decisions. It is also not the real story. I have made my living in real estate since 2003, through the 2008 crash and everything that happened after. So when the headlines started piling up this month, I did what I always do. I dug into the numbers to see what is actually there. Here is what I found. The real estate market is cracking, but NOT yet a crater, and it is not 2008. The way we combat fear is with real facts, without the colored commentary that adds sensationalized predictions or always tells us it is the perfect time to buy. So here is my raw analysis of the current state of the real estate market in America. Where the cracks are forming, how big they are, who is losing their homes and where, the dominoes that could make it bigger, and what I am watching. How big is this, really?At this year's pace, about 455,000 homes will get a foreclosure notice. For context: In 2006, about 718,000 homeowners got a foreclosure notice. 2007, 1.3 million. 2008, 2.3 million. 2009, 2.8 million. 2010, 2.9 million. So right now, there is a crack, but it is not dangerous yet. There is real trouble in some places, and I will show you where. But as you can see, we are nowhere near 2008 levels. That being said, foreclosures are indeed rising fast. It is just from a very low floor. Here is that number next to its history. U.S. properties with a foreclosure filing, by year.
In 2019, the last normal year before the pandemic, it was 493,000. So this year is on pace to land below 2019. We are rising back toward normal, not past it. What is noteworthy is that the number of homes in active foreclosure started climbing last fall and did not stop. In September it hit 303,000, up 37% in a year and the highest since early 2019. That count comes from Intercontinental Exchange, the company that owns the New York Stock Exchange. It tracks the payments on most of the mortgages in America, loan by loan. That is the crack. It is real and it is growing. Now the other half, the part the scary version leaves out. The share of all mortgages that are behind on payments is 3.66%. Most of us are paying our mortgage on time. More of us than in 2019. Three numbers that end the 2008 comparisonI know what some of you are thinking, because I thought it too. 2006 looked calm right before the storm. Why is this time different? Start with the loans. In 2006, millions of mortgages were adjustable, handed out to almost anyone, and built to reset to a higher payment after two or three years. When they reset, people could not pay. Today about 96% of mortgages are fixed. The payment we have is the payment we keep. Then the cushion. Half of all mortgages in America today carry a rate below 4%. American homeowners are sitting on about $18 trillion of equity, which is a record. That is $18 trillion of room to sell, refinance, or ride it out before a bad month becomes a lost house. In 2008, prices fell everywhere at once and millions of people owed more than their home was worth. That is what turns a crack into a crater, and it is not where we are. Now the three numbers. Before the crash, about 1 in every 100 mortgages was in foreclosure. At the 2010 peak, it was nearly 1 in 20. Today it is about 1 in 150. Share of U.S. mortgages in the foreclosure process, 2000 to 2026. Where a housing market bubble is bursting right nowAustralia. If we want to see how a crack turns into a crater, that is where to look. Australia looks more like the U.S. did in 2008, because about 80% of their mortgages are adjustable. When their central bank moves interest rates, almost every homeowner's payment moves within weeks. Their central bank cut rates hard before and during Covid, and every payment in the country dropped. That relief is what set up the crater. Cheap payments overheated the market, and home values jumped more than 30% in two years. Then the bill came due. Their central bank has raised rates five times this year in an effort to slow inflation, the latest on November 3, to the highest level since 2008. An Australian family that bought in 2020 is paying 73% more today for the same house, on the same loan. They did nothing. The rate did it. Home values in Australia's big cities have fallen 8% since March, the fastest drop there in 40 years. And they are not at the bottom. Australia's biggest bank now expects a 14% fall from the peak before prices stop, late next year. That would be the largest drop in their history. Australia: the monthly payment on the average mortgage, and the value of the typical home, 2015 to 2026. The dashed line is the bank's forecast.
My gut says it goes further than 14%. The bank's number assumes buyers step back. It does not account for sellers being forced to sell. Many owners have equity, but they may not be able to sustain the higher payments. That spikes supply further and creates panic price drops to entice buyers in a falling market. The drop feeds on itself, and that is how a 14% price drop pushes over 30%. I share this for two reasons. First, so we can see the difference between a crack and a crater. Second, because our own Fed raised rates in September into a slowing housing market, and may do it again in December. Since our mortgages are mostly fixed, when our rates rise the pain lands on the people buying now, not on everyone at once. Same rate hikes, very different crater. Who is actually losing their homes to foreclosure in AmericaHere is the part that might surprise you. Almost half of the homes going into foreclosure this year were bought in 2022 or later. Intercontinental Exchange says loans made in 2022 or after made up 49% of the foreclosures completed in September, and 43% of the new ones started. The people losing homes are not the ones who rode the wave up. They are the ones who bought recently. About 813,000 homeowners now owe more than their house is worth, up 44% in a year. Of those, 85% bought in 2022 or later, and three in four used a low down payment government loan, FHA or VA. The FHA numbers say it plainly. Almost 12% of FHA borrowers are behind on their payments. For conventional loans it is under 3%. The same house, $941 more a monthIn 2022, mortgage rates went from about 3% to about 7% in a few months. Home prices did not fall to match. They mostly went flat. Take a $386,000 loan, which is a $400,000 house with 3.5% down. At 3%, the payment on principal and interest is about $1,627 a month. At 7%, it is about $2,568. That is $941 more every month for the same house, almost 60% more. So a family that bought in 2023 is paying far more for the same house their neighbor bought in 2021, and it is not worth more today than they paid. Now add the down payment. A government loan lets a family in with 3.5% down. Down payment assistance programs, many of them run by states, can cover that 3.5% too. VA loans allow zero down. This really helps people become homeowners. It is also a fragile way in. Here is why. Say that family needs to sell after two and a half years, and the house sells for exactly what they paid, $400,000. They still owe about $381,800, because almost all of those early payments went to interest. Selling costs about 7%, or $28,000. After paying the loan and the costs, they are about $9,800 short. Underwater, and the price never fell. A rising market hides that. If prices had climbed 10%, that family would walk away with a check. A flat market hides nothing. So the first hiccup in life, a job loss, an illness, a divorce, hits a family with no cushion and no way to sell their way out. That is the crack, one house at a time. What a business owner sees that a homeowner missesA foreclosure is not the end of the world. A business owner knows that about failure, because we live with the odds every day. About 1 in 14 homeowners, roughly 5.5 million households, lost a home between 2005 and 2015, according to a Harvard study. Most of them recovered, rebuilt their credit, and many bought again. It costs years, not a lifetime. Buying a home is a bit like starting a business. There is risk, and most of us decide the benefits outweigh it. That is the decision every buyer makes. A business is far riskier, since most eventually fail. Right now 3.66% of mortgages are behind on payments, and well under 1% are in foreclosure. Historically, that is pretty good. So overall, buying a home is a good bet, and over the long term it is a fantastic bet. In the short term, with a low down payment, the risk is much higher, and we are seeing that reality play out now. Florida, Texas, and the Idaho number that surprised meIt is not spread evenly. Florida has the highest foreclosure rate in the country, one home in every 373. Then South Carolina, Indiana, Delaware and Illinois. The national rate is one in 632. The hardest-hit metros are mostly on Florida's Gulf Coast. Punta Gorda is at one home in every 200. Those are the same places where prices and the number of homes for sale peaked first, two years ago. Hold that thought about Florida, because it shows the order these things happen in. Prices there are already well off the peak: Punta Gorda down about 24%, Cape Coral down 19%, Sarasota down 17%. However, the supply of homes for sale there is now shrinking, by 19% in Cape Coral and 28% in Punta Gorda in a year. Part of that is buyers coming back, since sales are up about 9% in both. A house 20% cheaper finds a buyer. The bigger part is sellers who cannot get their price pulling listings, and builders who stopped building. The market is healing itself at a lower price. And the foreclosures are arriving last. The owners who bought at the 2022 peak are the ones who cannot sell their way out. Texas is the other big one. In August, more homes went back to the bank in Texas than in any other state, 1,835 of them, nearly a third of the national total. The three metros with the most were Houston, Dallas and San Antonio. Remember those three names. They come back in a minute. Idaho, where I live, shows up on one list, and it is the one that gets a scary headline. HEADLINE 1: Idaho had the fastest rise in foreclosure notices of any state in the country in the first half of the year, up 59%. Here is what that stat leaves out. That was 969 homes in six months, one in every 820, well below the national rate. HEADLINE 2: Idaho also has the lowest share of late mortgages of any state, at 2.1%. Up 59% from almost nothing is still almost nothing. Further proof of how headlines can be scary and misleading at the same time. How a crack becomes a crater, step by stepThis is the part I am watching, and it starts with builders. Builders are sitting on 111,000 finished new homes that nobody has bought. That is almost four times the number from early 2022, and it adds up to about eight and a half months of supply. Six months is a normal year. A builder pays interest on every one of those houses every month. A homeowner can wait. A builder cannot. So builders cut. They cut the price, they pay down the buyer's interest rate, they throw in the appliances. Those incentives run about 7% to 8% of the price, and most of them never show up in the reported numbers. The first major warning sign in the new construction market is here. The median new home in America now sells for less than the median existing home. In September it was $400,400 for new against $417,500 for existing. For context, a new home cost more than a used one every single year for 50 years. The gap closed in 2024, tied in 2025, and this year it flipped. How much more the median new home cost than the median existing home, each year since 1975. In San Antonio, Austin, Dallas, Raleigh and Tampa, a new house is now cheaper per square foot than the used house next door. Houston, Dallas and San Antonio are also the three metros where the most homes went back to the bank in August. That is not a coincidence. Here is the chain of events, and how it happens.
That is how a builder dropping prices in Texas ends up as an uptick in the national foreclosure count. And it is why foreclosures are the last domino, not the first. Florida's Gulf Coast is two years ahead of the rest of the country, and it shows the order: supply up, prices down, supply clears, then the foreclosures arrive. Two kinds of cities, two different problemsYou can see the slow version of this in the national numbers. Homes listed for sale are up 5% from a year ago, while new listings are down. Homes are not flooding the market. They are just not selling. Supply slowly rises while demand slows. But the national number hides where it is happening. It is happening in two kinds of cities, for two reasons that end up in the same place. First, the places that built the most. Austin, Nashville, Charlotte, Raleigh, Phoenix and the big Texas metros led the country in new construction during the boom. Homes for sale are 58% above 2019 levels in Austin, 55% in Nashville, 49% in San Antonio. Builders there still have to sell, so they cut first. Second, the places that simply got too expensive. Seattle, Denver, Washington DC, Minneapolis and Charlotte have each added 50% to 74% more homes for sale in two years, and they did not overbuild. Fewer buyers can qualify at today's prices and a 7% rate, so homes sit, and sitting is what raises supply. Change in homes for sale by metro, last 24 months A few things worth noticing. Washington DC leads at +74%, and most of that came in 2025, when the federal layoffs hit the one city where the government is the biggest employer. Seattle, Louisville, Indianapolis and Charlotte round out the top five, none of them boom-town builders. Boise is at +1%. Chicago, San Francisco, Jacksonville and Florida's Gulf Coast are below zero. Change in homes for sale by metro, last 12 months The last 12 months tell a different story.
Either way, the result is the same. Supply rises because demand fell, and prices are starting to follow. Over the four weeks ending October 25, sale prices were down 5% in Seattle and 3% to 5% in San Jose, Austin, Kansas City and Nashville. So what about Boise?Boise, where I live, is moving the other way. It has 8% fewer homes for sale than a year ago while the country has 5% more. Part of the reason is that Boise already took its hit. We were the first market in the country to turn in 2022. Listings peaked that fall, prices came down, and the market has been working through it since. So a Boise buyer from 2022 is a different question than an Austin buyer from 2022. That question deserves its own letter, and I will do a deep dive on the Boise market in my next letter. The questions I keep gettingI keep hearing there is a housing shortage. How can there be too many homes? Both are true. The country is still 9% short of the number of homes for sale it had in 2019. What is piling up is homes at a price people cannot afford at a 7% rate. Lennar, one of the biggest builders, said half the people who toured its homes last quarter could not qualify for a mortgage. Prices are still going up, so where is the crash? The national median sale price was up 1.3% from a year ago in September, which after inflation is roughly flat or even down slightly. Then in late October, Redfin's median sale price slipped 0.1% below a year ago, the first annual decline in more than three years. One in five listings has had a price cut. Then why does it feel so slow? Because the demand side has gone quiet in a way we have not seen before. The Realtors’ index of pending home sales, which counts signed contracts, fell to 66 in September. The index started in 2001 at 100. It has never been lower. The bottom of the 2008 crash was 80. The Covid lockdown was 71.6. Pending home sales index, 2005 to 2026.
Flat is the word, and it just tipped. It is not a crash, and it is not a boom. It is a market where the people who can buy already did, and the people who want to buy cannot. Is my house worth less now? If you bought before 2021, almost certainly not. The crack is in the newest loans and the most overbuilt markets. If you bought in the last three years in one of the cities mentioned above, it depends on the street. Where I landReal estate has always been a location-driven market. Some of the hottest markets in the country (Austin, Seattle, Denver, Nashville, Charlotte) are showing the first warning signs of trouble as their supply of homes for sale rises significantly. These hot markets are all experiencing the same problem. Real estate has become too expensive for more and more buyers. So expect prices to soften as their supply of homes for sale grows. It is what you would expect after mortgage rates have sat near 7% for four years. The buyers who could buy did. Now the number of buyers who can afford to buy is shrinking, in an economy that is proving shaky. If mortgage rates were at 3.5%, those markets would still have a low supply of homes and prices would still be rising. The rest of the economy is not helping. A stock market held up by a handful of AI companies showed how fragile that is late last month, and wars and trade fights overseas trickle down into everything, including housing. It is important to remember that real estate does not change overnight. It changes over months and years, which is why I study it. You can see the signs coming and adapt before they arrive. And here is the part that is working, because something always is. Most homeowners in the country still hold a fixed rate below 4%. Most of us have more equity in our homes than we have ever had. Fewer of us are behind on our mortgage than in 2019. So the trouble we are seeing is real, yet concentrated in the newest loans and the most overbuilt cities, not spread across the country. What I'm watching nextIn order:
One last thingHalloween was last month, a time of year when many of us watch something scary. A scary movie works because it gets our emotions going. The scarier it is, the more popular it becomes. And when it ends, we are okay, because we know it was just a movie. It cannot hurt us. Most of the news we read is built the same way. The scarier the story, the more it gets shared, so the stories get scarier, which triggers our emotions and fears. That version of this letter is the one I showed you at the top. I did not send it, because I write these letters with the opposite intent. I write them so that when we read the next scary headline, we know what is actually going on and what is not, and we make our next decision with a clear head instead of a racing heart. That is the whole game. It is why I study markets. Understanding something is the fastest way I know to be less afraid of it. If this sparked a thought, or you see it differently, hit reply. That's all for today. Cheers, Mike T. P.S. One idea I keep coming back to. If more loans were assumable, meaning the next buyer could take over the existing loan and its rate, then a family that can no longer afford their payment in a cool housing market would have a way out. They could sell the house with the 3% loan attached, and buyers would line up for it. It would act as a backstop against default across the whole market. The mortgage industry makes billions in new loan fees, so it is a hard sell, and it would likely take a government mandate. But it is a real lever, and it deserves its own letter. Who is writing. My name is Mike Turner. I am an entrepreneur, a father, and a husband, and I have been a full-time real estate investor and business owner for more than 20 years. I am curious about people, history, and how the world works, and I write these letters following that curiosity, sorting actual facts out of the noise. They come from a pull I feel to lead by sharing what I am learning and to make meaningful impact where I can. I am not selling anything, I no longer take on clients, and I am not a financial advisor. What you get here is research, insight, and my opinion, never a recommendation. If you find it useful, share it, or don’t. If you think I am missing something, or have a topic you want covered, reply. I read every one. ### Forwarded by a friend? Get the Letter |
Every week I write a letter about what I'm seeing in the world and in life, and my thoughts on how it may impact us locally and personally. An honest take, with no spin or agenda.I'm a former ship captain, Coast Guard officer, and 25-year entrepreneur. I started out on the path I thought I was supposed to follow: work hard in school, get the good job, climb the ladder, commute in the suit and tie. Then I proved to myself that I could make it on my own, building work that helped people while giving my family a kind of freedom no salary could, and I never looked back. Raising a family with no safety net of steady income forced me to get creative, to build whatever skill the moment demanded, and to pay close attention to how money, economies, and politics really work, because when there's no net, you can't afford to be blindsided by the next storm. I've failed more times than I can count. The difference is I never stopped looking for a way up the mountain. And somewhere on that climb I learned the truth about the mountain: there's no summit where everything finally gets better. You have to fall in love with the journey as it unfolds, even when it's hard and the future is uncertain. That's the aim underneath everything I do: living well.My goal with these letters is simply to give. Not to sell you anything, not to convince you of anything. Just to share what I'm learning on my journey, and insights that might prove helpful in yours.
Most of what keeps our lights on was built by our grandparents.Our power bills are going up. And a way to fix it that is being tested an hour from Boise, Idaho. Mike Turner | Oct 25, 2026 Gas and diesel are still near record highs, and our power bills are going up on top of them. It is obvious to most of us that the wars are driving fuel prices. What surprised me, when I started digging into how America makes and moves its energy, is how little of it we have built in my lifetime. Most of what...
A solution to $5 gas prices: I am calling it the "American Backstop."The easy fixes all fail for the same reason. Here is the deal I would offer instead, and who gets to own it. (Part 3 of 3) Mike Turner | Oct 5, 2026 Is it right that refineries are posting record profits while the rest of us pay $5 a gallon? Should the government do something about it? And what could be done that is fair to the private company and to the American public? Those are the questions readers have been sending me...
Crude fell $10 a barrel. The pump went up anyway. Why?Where the money is going, and why nobody has built a refinery in almost 50 years. (Part 2 of 3) Mike Turner | Oct 3, 2026 A barrel of crude oil fell $10 the week of September 18. The price at the pump went up anyway. How does that happen? Are refineries and gas companies making record profits because the world is bidding up the price of fuel? And is that right, given how hard our economy is being hit by it? And why has nobody built a new...