Crude fell $10 a barrel. The pump went up anyway. Why?


Crude fell $10 a barrel.
The pump went up anyway. Why?
​Where the money is going, and why nobody has built a refinery in almost 50 years.
(Part 2 of 3)

Mike Turner | Oct 3, 2026

A barrel of crude oil fell $10 the week of September 18. The price at the pump went up anyway.

How does that happen?

Are refineries and gas companies making record profits because the world is bidding up the price of fuel? And is that right, given how hard our economy is being hit by it?

And why has nobody built a new refinery in this country in almost 50 years? Should we, if we keep moving away from fossil fuels?

They are one story: where the money is going.

What should be done about it, and what the government's role is, comes in my next letter.

Crude fell $10 in a week. The pump went up. Here is how that happens.

A barrel got cheaper and a gallon got more expensive in the same week. That can only happen if the money is being made somewhere between the barrel and the pump. It is.

Think of a refinery as a bakery. Crude oil is the flour. Gasoline and diesel are the bread. The refinery's markup is the difference between what it pays for the flour and what it sells the bread for.

Here it is in barrels. A barrel of crude oil cost about $96 this week.

In a normal year, a refinery turns that barrel into diesel and sells it for $15 to $25 more than it paid for the crude. That is the markup.

This week it is selling that same barrel of diesel for about $110 more than it paid for the crude. The markup passed $100 for the first time ever in August.

Here is what that means at the pump. A barrel is 42 gallons, so a $110 markup is about $2.60 of every gallon of diesel going to the refinery. In a normal year that piece is about 50 cents.

So when the flour got cheaper for a week and the bread kept going up, that was the bakery's markup getting bigger. The industry calls it the crack spread. I will just call it the markup.

Refineries are making extraordinary profits right now

Marathon, Phillips 66 and Valero earned $12.6 billion between them in the second quarter, the most since the year Russia invaded Ukraine. They handed $6.3 billion of it back to shareholders, more than double the year before.

That was April through June. The third quarter ended on Wednesday, and the markup ran higher through this last quarter, so profits will be even higher. The companies report later this month. I would expect the number to be much bigger.

I want to be fair about what that markup is, because it is not all profit. Out of it a refinery pays its people, its maintenance, and the natural gas it burns to run the plant, which is expensive right now too. Call it $5 to $8 a barrel. That still leaves a lot.

I know what a lot of us are thinking when we hear those numbers, because I thought it too. Every time the world catches fire, the oil companies post a record and the rest of us pay for it at the pump.

That feels wrong, and I am not going to pretend it does not.

But before we decide what to do about it, we need to understand all the mechanisms behind it first. That is the goal of this letter. My next letter will be focused on what can and should be done going forward.

Refinery profits are soaring with the increase in demand, and here is the important detail: because there are not enough refineries, and the ones we have are running flat out.

American refineries have been running at 96 to 98 percent of capacity almost every week since July. They are running at full capacity. There is no spare.

When Exxon's big refinery outside Chicago lost power in mid-September and went down for more than a week, it took about eight percent of the Midwest's refining with it. Michigan diesel jumped 66 cents in seven days. There was nothing to fill the gap.

And here is the part I keep chewing on. When refineries are making massive profits like they are now, that would normally drive the market to create more refineries. That is what high prices are supposed to do: make a thing so profitable that somebody builds more of it, until there is enough and the price comes back down.

Nobody is building more refineries.

Here is the number that surprised me most.

The last big refinery built in the United States opened in 1977, in Garyville, Louisiana. Not one has been built since. In that time the population has grown by more than 50%.

Our refining capacity has not grown at all. We have about what we had in 1981.

The plants that survived got bigger and the rest closed, so we make it in about 130 plants today instead of more than 300. That worked, as long as nothing broke.

And now the old ones are starting to close.

Two California refineries shut down in the past year, taking about a fifth of that state's capacity with them. I wanted to know why, because if they are breaking, others will follow.

They are not breaking, exactly. They are old. Several California refineries were built more than a hundred years ago, and even the newest predates modern environmental law. Old plants cost more to run and more to keep running.

California's own gasoline use has fallen 15 percent since 2005, and the state's energy commission says more of its refineries will likely close. The owners looked ten and twenty years down the road and did not like what they saw. A Houston refinery closed last year for much the same reason.

So it is not one broken part. It is a fleet of very old plants in a country that has not decided whether it wants more of them.

And that is the refinery owner's own math, not an environmental argument.

A refinery is a forty-year asset that takes a decade to permit. If a high percentage of cars on the road in 2040 do not burn gasoline, nobody builds a plant today to make it.

California's gasoline use is already falling. Driverless taxis are carrying passengers in a handful of cities, more than four thousand of them as of last week, most of them electric, and the companies behind them are planning for far more. Some freight fleets are starting to move trucks to electric too.

Should we build more refineries if that is where the road is going? That is the question every refinery owner is asking, and it is why the answer so far is no.

The high gas prices are the market shouting for more refineries. At the same time, the market is telling anyone who might build one that the customer may not be there by the time it opens.

How long would it take to build a new refinery? Nobody knows, because nobody has finished one.

The one serious attempt, a small refinery in North Dakota, was proposed in 2016, fought through two lawsuits, got its last permit in 2022, and has not broken ground. Ten years, no refinery.

The industry's own figure for simply reaching the point of breaking ground is $500 million to $1 billion, most of it studies, permits and the lawsuits that follow. Then you build, and then you hope the country still wants what you make forty years from now.

And the West Coast, which just lost a fifth of its refining capability, has no pipeline to the Gulf. Which brings me to a law I learned about in college and had mostly forgotten.

How the Jones Act raises the price of fuel

Since 1920, any cargo moving by ship between two American ports has to travel on a ship built in America, owned by Americans and crewed by Americans. It is called the Jones Act, and it was written to keep our shipyards alive. That was a wise idea when we built ships.

But we mostly do not anymore. For many decades, American-built ships have cost several times more to build than foreign ones, so there are very few of them, and it is not getting better.

For most of a century it has been cheaper to move fuel across this country by truck than by water, and California's gasoline has come from India and South Korea, because a foreign tanker from Asia can legally deliver to Los Angeles and a foreign tanker from Texas cannot.

In March, Washington waived the Jones Act for fuel to help keep fuel prices lower. It has extended the waiver twice, now through November 15.

Since then, fuel shipped from the Gulf Coast to the West Coast has gone from under 30,000 barrels a day to about 190,000, most of it on foreign tankers.

That is a big part of why the West Coast pays more for fuel than the southern Gulf states do.

If the Jones Act were not temporarily switched off right now, the West Coast would be paying far higher fuel prices than it is right now.

A hundred-year-old law is currently switched off, and someone in Washington has to decide in November whether to switch it back on.

A couple of questions I was pondering

What about the emergency reserve? You may have read that it is at its lowest level since 1982, and that is true. It is about 40 percent full.

But that reserve holds crude oil, the flour, not gasoline, the bread, and as we just saw, the bakeries are already running flat out. Pouring more flour into a full bakery does not make more bread.

The nation's reserve has been drawn down every week since spring under a plan announced in March, and the oil companies have to return those barrels later. The plan to refill it with Venezuelan crude will take years, because Venezuelan crude is too heavy to go in the tank as it is.

What about hurricanes? A number of times in the past, Gulf Coast refineries have been hit by hurricanes that halted production. More than half the country's refining sits on the Gulf Coast, and the 2026 hurricane season runs through November. And by some miracle, as of this week there has not been a single Atlantic hurricane this year. The last season to reach October without one was 1914.

So some of the fuel price we are paying today is good luck. If a hurricane hits those refineries, prices will soar.

What comes next

In the short term, if you live in the western states, hope that the Jones Act stays paused beyond November.

For all Americans, and for everyone in the world who buys our fuel, hope that no hurricane hits any of our coastal refineries this year.

That leaves the questions I have not answered.

Is it right that refineries are seeing record profits while the country suffers under high fuel prices?

What should the oil companies do with their record profits? What is the government's role, and what could be done?

Texas switched on its price gouging law this week.

Some in Washington want to ban fuel exports.

Others want to tax the profits.

I looked at all three, and at what I would do instead. That is what I am covering in my next letter, coming out in the next couple days.

If you see this differently, or you believe I am missing something in my analysis, reply. I want to know, and I read every response.

That's all for today.

Cheers,

Mike T.

###

P.S. If this landed in your inbox from a friend, here is who is writing. My name is Mike Turner. I am an entrepreneur, a father, and a husband, and I am curious about people, history, and how the world works. I write these letters following my own curiosity, sorting actual facts out of the noise, and my only aim is to inform. I am not selling anything, I do not take on clients, and I am not a financial advisor. I invest in my own local market, and I feel compelled to share what I learn along the way. What you get here is research, insight, and my opinion, never a recommendation. If you find it useful, share it, or don't. If you think I am missing something, or have a topic you want covered, reply. I read every one.


Mike Turner
​
​IG: @miketurnerlife
FB:
@miketurnerboise​
​
LI: @miketurnerlife

Forwarded by a friend? Get the Letter​
​
​
Manage Which Emails You Get...
https://preview.convertkit-mail4.com/preferences
​
​

GROUND LEVEL: a weekly letter about what I'm seeing in the world, and what it could mean for us locally and personally.

Every week I write a letter about what I'm seeing in the world and in life, and my thoughts on how it may impact us locally and personally. An honest take, with no spin or agenda.I'm a former ship captain, Coast Guard officer, and 25-year entrepreneur. I started out on the path I thought I was supposed to follow: work hard in school, get the good job, climb the ladder, commute in the suit and tie. Then I proved to myself that I could make it on my own, building work that helped people while giving my family a kind of freedom no salary could, and I never looked back. Raising a family with no safety net of steady income forced me to get creative, to build whatever skill the moment demanded, and to pay close attention to how money, economies, and politics really work, because when there's no net, you can't afford to be blindsided by the next storm. I've failed more times than I can count. The difference is I never stopped looking for a way up the mountain. And somewhere on that climb I learned the truth about the mountain: there's no summit where everything finally gets better. You have to fall in love with the journey as it unfolds, even when it's hard and the future is uncertain. That's the aim underneath everything I do: living well.My goal with these letters is simply to give. Not to sell you anything, not to convince you of anything. Just to share what I'm learning on my journey, and insights that might prove helpful in yours.

Read more from GROUND LEVEL: a weekly letter about what I'm seeing in the world, and what it could mean for us locally and personally.

U.S. Housing Market is Cracking. How Bad is it?New homes now cost less than existing ones for the first time in 50 years. Here is what that means. Mike Turner | Nov 8, 2026 Writing this one from the patio, with a live soundtrack. Seven charts and two weeks of digging, condensed to one Sunday read. I could have written the scariest housing story you have read all year. The numbers are sitting right there. If I were a news outlet, a podcast host, or a YouTuber who needed your click, here is how...

Most of what keeps our lights on was built by our grandparents.Our power bills are going up. And a way to fix it that is being tested an hour from Boise, Idaho. Mike Turner | Oct 25, 2026 Gas and diesel are still near record highs, and our power bills are going up on top of them. It is obvious to most of us that the wars are driving fuel prices. What surprised me, when I started digging into how America makes and moves its energy, is how little of it we have built in my lifetime. Most of what...

A solution to $5 gas prices: I am calling it the "American Backstop."The easy fixes all fail for the same reason. Here is the deal I would offer instead, and who gets to own it. (Part 3 of 3) Mike Turner | Oct 5, 2026 Is it right that refineries are posting record profits while the rest of us pay $5 a gallon? Should the government do something about it? And what could be done that is fair to the private company and to the American public? Those are the questions readers have been sending me...