A solution to $5 gas prices: I am calling it the American Backstop.


A solution to $5 gas prices: I am calling it the "American Backstop."
​The easy fixes all fail for the same reason. Here is the deal I would offer instead, and who gets to own it. (Part 3 of 3)

Mike Turner | Oct 5, 2026

Is it right that refineries are posting record profits while the rest of us pay $5 a gallon?

Should the government do something about it?

And what could be done that is fair to the private company and to the American public?

Those are the questions readers have been sending me since my first letter. People want to know what can be done, if anything.

I have a proposal that could help with the fuel crisis we are in now and, more importantly, help prevent the next one. That is what this letter is about, a way out of this mess.

I am calling it the AMERICAN BACKSTOP.

First, let me quickly recap where we stand.

America is NOT short of gasoline. The world is short of fuel, and our fuel is leaving the country for the highest bidder, which takes our price up with it.

The price of a barrel of crude has not moved that much, but refinery profits are skyrocketing. There is not enough competition between refineries, because nobody has built one in almost 50 years.

If you missed the last letter, the number to know is the markup, the gross profit a refinery makes on a barrel of oil. Normally it runs $15 to $25 a barrel. This week it is about $110. They are making a killing while American citizens get hammered.

Is it right?

I will be honest that this one got under my skin.

I run businesses. I believe a well run company earns every dollar, and I do not want the government in the room telling me how much I can make.

But there is a difference between earning more and collecting more. A company earns more by serving its customers better than the competition, by inventing something. That is the American way and I would defend it all day.

What we are watching is not that. Nobody at a refinery got smarter this summer. Wars on the other side of the world are taking fuel off the market, and American refineries are charging whatever the shortage will bear. Hence the record profits.

Translation: oil company profits spike when the world is in chaos. This chart shows it clearly.

In a market that works, a profit like that is temporary. It is the signal to the marketplace to go build more, and when more gets built the price comes down and the windfall ends. However, that signal has been flashing since 1977. Nobody has built more.

The problem is that it currently takes a decade to get through the permitting to even start building a refinery, years more to build it, and it is unclear whether it will even be needed by the time it is done. So the problem continues.

So the question is not whether their record profits are right. It is what would have to change so new energy infrastructure actually gets built when it is needed.

Solutions politicians often propose, and why they fail

You are going to hear four fixes in the news over the next few weeks and months. All of them have the same inherent problem. They may sound like the right idea, but they will ultimately fail for the same reason.

1. The price gouging law. Texas switched its on last week. It makes it illegal to sell fuel at an "exorbitant or excessive price" during a declared disaster. The problem with using it now is that it was written for the gas station that triples its price before a hurricane. A refinery's price is what the world pays for its fuel, and it is hard to call a price exorbitant when it is the same price in Europe.

2. The windfall tax. About a dozen senators want to tax half the industry's profits above pre-war levels and send the money to lower-income households. We did it in 1980. That tax raised about a fifth of what was promised, oil companies ended up producing less domestic oil, and it was repealed early.

3. The export ban. We make the diesel here, so why do Americans have to pay Europe's price for it? The problem is the mechanism. If refineries cannot sell diesel overseas, the Gulf Coast fills up with diesel it cannot move, the refineries run less crude, and less crude means less of everything, including gasoline. A ban meant to lower diesel could push gasoline to a record.

4. The margin cap. California recently tried this. In 2023 it passed a law letting the state cap refinery margins and fine any refiner that went over. Within two years, two refineries announced they were shutting down. In August 2025 the state shelved the cap for at least five years.

Here is what all four have in common. Each one takes something from the refinery and gives nothing back. No protection in the bad years, no long contract, no reason to build or expand. They are all half a deal.

A refinery cannot move. But it can close, and some may have to if the government steps in to control their business and profits, which makes the problem worse.

What would work, and it has already been proven

A solution occurred to me when I started thinking about my own power bill.

Idaho Power is a private company with shareholders who want a profit, same as any refinery. It is also the only company allowed to sell electricity to most of southern Idaho. In its territory it is a monopoly, and the law treats it like one.

The deal works like this. The state grants the monopoly. In exchange, the company gives up the right to set its own price.

Three commissioners appointed by the governor set the rates. The company adds up what it spent to build and run the system, the commission goes through it line by line and asks whether each dollar was spent wisely, and the company is allowed a fixed return on what it invested.

Right now that return is 9.6 percent a year. The last electricity rate change gave them a 7.5 percent increase this January, and every dollar of it was argued in public.

What I like about that is the audit. It is not a one-time law.

It is a standing group that meets, looks at the actual numbers, and adjusts.

If the company overspends, the commission can refuse to let it recover the money. If costs fall, the commission pushes rates down. Nobody has to guess whether the company is being fair. Someone is paid to check.

If Idaho Power's costs doubled tomorrow, our rates would go up, but its profit would not. If a war tripled the price of electricity on the open market, Idaho Power would not get to keep the difference. That is the whole point of the deal.

And it rewards building. A utility earns its return on what it has invested, so the way to make more money is to build more. A utility that proposes a new plant gets a review and then a promised return for decades. A refiner that proposes a new refinery gets ten years of lawsuits and a coin flip. Do you see the difference?

Idaho is not the only place this works. Britain gets its power plants built with a contract that sets the electricity price for fifteen years: when the market is above it, the builder pays the difference back, and when the market is below it, the builder gets topped up. The guaranteed floor is what let builders take on the risk of borrowing, and it took offshore wind from the most expensive power in the country to among the cheapest in about ten years.

Australia is now down to its last two refineries. The government pays these privately owned companies a small price protection payment when margins fall below a threshold, in exchange for a signed commitment to keep running through 2030. In five years it has only had to pay out twice. Both refineries are still open.

Now look at California again. The state set a limit on refinery gross profit margins, but offered no protection if margins fell. It was half the deal: a forced profit cap with no protection and no long-term commitment in return. Two refineries announced they were closing.

The American Backstop

Here is the idea, in one sentence. The government guarantees a price protection floor on things of national importance, in exchange for a gross profit cap, oversight and a long commitment, and in the good years it collects.

To be clear, this is not the government building things.

This is not the government spending big.

It is the government standing behind the risk, so that the people who would build and improve essential infrastructure can borrow, while providing consumer protection against price gouging.

Here is how it would work for a refinery.

The government and the refinery agree on a fair gross margin, the markup, on the American share of its output. Call it $30 a barrel, a little above the normal $15 to $25, so it is worth signing.

The refinery keeps running exactly as it does now. It sells every barrel at the world price. It exports whatever it wants.

The price and terms are settled on paper at the end of each quarter, not at the pump. If the refinery's gross margin on the American share came in above $30, the refinery pays the difference into a fund. If it came in below $30, the fund pays the refinery.

Exports are outside the deal entirely, sold at whatever the world will pay.

This year a Gulf Coast refinery would be paying about $80 a barrel into the fund on its American share, and keeping every dollar of the markup on its exports. In 2020, when the markup fell to $10, the fund would have been paying that refinery $20 a barrel to stay open.

A guaranteed return in the bad years. A capped return in the good years.

Freedom to chase the world price on everything beyond the American share. That is the Idaho Power trade, written for a company that sells to the world.

The American share is not a guess. The country uses about 20 million barrels of fuel a day, and the government knows it to the barrel.

Put the American Backstop in action, and the export ban becomes unnecessary, because the refinery already gave up the windfall on the fuel it sells to the American market.

The windfall tax becomes unnecessary, because the refineries would be paying into a fund that protects them if margins drop.

Offer that same contract on new refining capacity for twenty years, and a bank will lend against it. A bank will not lend against a coin flip on unknown future market conditions. That is why Britain's wind infrastructure got built, and why a North Dakota refinery that has been trying since 2016 has not broken ground.

Where this idea has holes, and ways to fix them

Every idea breaks somewhere, and this one breaks in four potential places. We should know them.

1. No refiner signs this today. With the markup at $110, a $30 deal means handing back $80 of gross margin per barrel. The only time anyone signs is in a normal year, when $30 looks generous and a protection floor looks valuable.

This should have been on the table in 2015, or 2019, or 2024. It was not, because nobody was paying $5.

One thing changes that. The louder the public gets, the louder the calls for an export ban and a windfall tax get, and at some point a refiner looks at a ban it cannot control and a deal it can, and picks the deal. The threat is real leverage. It should be used to get the long deal signed, not to push a short-term punishment.

2. The accounting is gameable. The big refiners own the pipeline and sometimes the station, and the markup depends on where you measure it.

The fix is what they did with Idaho Power: settle on the published prices the whole industry already trades on, not the company's books, and put a standing commission on it that meets, looks at the numbers, and adjusts.

3. Someone carries the protection floor in the bad years. In 2020 this proposed fund would have paid out billions, from the paying-in years, and if the bad years persisted, potentially from the government as the backstop, as the exception, not the rule.

4. It has to be a deal, not a decree. These are privately owned companies. If the government imposes restrictions without protection and a long-term contract, it is California, and a refinery can close or fail.

One more thing it is not. In the 1970s the government capped the price of gasoline at the pump, and we got lines around the block, because a cap on the price makes supply disappear.

A protection floor and a cap on the markup, settled in cash after the fact, leaves every gallon selling at the market price. Nobody gets price gouged. The refineries get the money back through the fund when they need it. That is the difference between managing a price and managing a windfall.

What is the American Backstop for

I have spent three letters on fuel, but the Backstop is bigger than refineries, and this is the part I actually care about. It does three things.

It protects us from the next spike.

This fall is the clearest example in years of what happens when the country does not have enough of something it cannot do without. The price does not go up a little. It goes up until people stop buying, and the people who stop first are the citizens who get hurt the most by it.

A Backstop does not stop a war.

It makes sure that when the war comes, the plants are there, and the windfall flows back to the people paying for it instead of just to shareholders.

It is not only fuel.

The grid, the power plants, the ports, the ships.

My last letter showed what a hundred-year-old shipping law does when we are running out of U.S. built ships. It is the same problem with the refineries. Right now, nobody is building them because the risk is too high without a protection floor and a long-term agreement. The American Backstop could reverse that.

It lets us own a piece of it.

A guaranteed return with oversight is something a regular person can invest in. That is what a utility stock is. Idaho Power's parent company has paid its shareholders for decades, and a lot of those shareholders are retirees and pension funds in Idaho, people who own a piece of the thing they pay a bill to.

If we backstop the next generation of energy and infrastructure the same way, we are not just building plants. We are creating a place where ordinary citizens can own a share of the country's infrastructure and earn a guaranteed return that outpaces inflation, which, if you have been reading these letters, is a growing problem that does not get talked about nearly enough.

It lets the government speed things up instead of slowing them down.

One of the main reasons nobody builds a refinery is the ten years of permits and lawsuits before a shovel goes in the ground.

Now imagine the government is a participant in the project instead of only its regulator. It has signed the twenty-year deal. It has a stake in the plant opening.

It is no longer the thing standing between the builder and the ground; it is on the builder's side of the table, with every reason to clear the path.

Guardrails matter, and nothing should get built unsafe. But there is a difference between guardrails and ten years of paperwork, and we have confused the two for half a century.

Think about what the government's job actually is.

First, protect the citizens. The military is the easy example.

Second, make sure the things we need to function and prosper get built, which is the roads, the grid, the ports, and once upon a time, the plants that made fuel.

Those two jobs are as old as the country. The second one got dropped somewhere around the time we stopped building refineries, and it is not one party's fault. Every administration since 1977 has had a turn.

This is not about letting companies make more money, nor is it about more government spending. It is about not getting overrun by the cost of energy because there is not enough of it. That is the direction we are headed.

The Backstop costs money only in the bad years. In the good years it collects. That is a different thing from writing checks.

One more thing

The last time gas spiked like this, I bought an electric car. Not to save the world. I bought it because I did not know where the price was going, and I wanted one bill in my life that was not set by a war on the other side of it.

I am not telling anyone to buy a car or put panels on a roof. The principle underneath it is the one I keep coming back to in these letters. Reduce the number of prices in your life that you cannot control.

The demand for fuel is not going away. It is moving. Every electric car and panel on a roof takes a gallon out of this story and puts a kilowatt into a different one. The grid that has to carry it, the solar farms, the charging stations, the nuclear plants, the lines between them, all come back to the same question we just asked about refineries: who is building. The Backstop might be how they get built. I will dig into this more in my next letter.

If you see this differently, or you believe I am missing something, reply. I want to know, and I read every response.

That's all for today.

Cheers,

Mike T.

###

P.S. If this landed in your inbox from a friend, here is who is writing. My name is Mike Turner. I am an entrepreneur, a father, and a husband, and I am curious about people, history, and how the world works. I write these letters following my own curiosity, sorting actual facts out of the noise, and my only aim is to inform. I am not selling anything, I do not take on clients, and I am not a financial advisor. I invest in my own local market, and I feel compelled to share what I learn along the way. What you get here is research, insight, and my opinion, never a recommendation. If you find it useful, share it, or don't. If you think I am missing something, or have a topic you want covered, reply. I read every one.


Mike Turner
​
​IG: @miketurnerlife
FB:
@miketurnerboise​
​
LI: @miketurnerlife

Forwarded by a friend? Get the Letter​
​
​
Manage Which Emails You Get...
https://preview.convertkit-mail4.com/preferences
​
​

GROUND LEVEL: a weekly letter about what I'm seeing in the world, and what it could mean for us locally and personally.

Every week I write a letter about what I'm seeing in the world and in life, and my thoughts on how it may impact us locally and personally. An honest take, with no spin or agenda.I'm a former ship captain, Coast Guard officer, and 25-year entrepreneur. I started out on the path I thought I was supposed to follow: work hard in school, get the good job, climb the ladder, commute in the suit and tie. Then I proved to myself that I could make it on my own, building work that helped people while giving my family a kind of freedom no salary could, and I never looked back. Raising a family with no safety net of steady income forced me to get creative, to build whatever skill the moment demanded, and to pay close attention to how money, economies, and politics really work, because when there's no net, you can't afford to be blindsided by the next storm. I've failed more times than I can count. The difference is I never stopped looking for a way up the mountain. And somewhere on that climb I learned the truth about the mountain: there's no summit where everything finally gets better. You have to fall in love with the journey as it unfolds, even when it's hard and the future is uncertain. That's the aim underneath everything I do: living well.My goal with these letters is simply to give. Not to sell you anything, not to convince you of anything. Just to share what I'm learning on my journey, and insights that might prove helpful in yours.

Read more from GROUND LEVEL: a weekly letter about what I'm seeing in the world, and what it could mean for us locally and personally.

U.S. Housing Market is Cracking. How Bad is it?New homes now cost less than existing ones for the first time in 50 years. Here is what that means. Mike Turner | Nov 8, 2026 Writing this one from the patio, with a live soundtrack. Seven charts and two weeks of digging, condensed to one Sunday read. I could have written the scariest housing story you have read all year. The numbers are sitting right there. If I were a news outlet, a podcast host, or a YouTuber who needed your click, here is how...

Most of what keeps our lights on was built by our grandparents.Our power bills are going up. And a way to fix it that is being tested an hour from Boise, Idaho. Mike Turner | Oct 25, 2026 Gas and diesel are still near record highs, and our power bills are going up on top of them. It is obvious to most of us that the wars are driving fuel prices. What surprised me, when I started digging into how America makes and moves its energy, is how little of it we have built in my lifetime. Most of what...

Crude fell $10 a barrel. The pump went up anyway. Why?Where the money is going, and why nobody has built a refinery in almost 50 years. (Part 2 of 3) Mike Turner | Oct 3, 2026 A barrel of crude oil fell $10 the week of September 18. The price at the pump went up anyway. How does that happen? Are refineries and gas companies making record profits because the world is bidding up the price of fuel? And is that right, given how hard our economy is being hit by it? And why has nobody built a new...