The U.S. is not short of gasoline.
|
Until about 1981, the two lines rise and fall together. Then they split, and diesel never came back. I wondered why nobody tried to rebuild it, so I looked.
In 1979, after the oil shocks, the Department of Energy wanted 240 million barrels of heating oil, the same family of fuel as diesel, in the tanks by October 1.
Then we built the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which holds crude oil in caverns. That moved the nation's cushion out of the private fuel tanks and into the ground.
After that, nobody in the market got paid to hold extra fuel, so nobody did. As far as I can find, the only time we ever built a deep diesel cushion was when the government demanded it.
The European Union still does: its members must hold at least 90 days of net imports, or 61 days of consumption, in reserve.
Cheap-fuel years came and went for forty years, and nobody used them to refill the tanks. That is the diesel problem in one sentence, and arguably it highlights a leadership problem.
The issue today is that everyone else who imports fuel now has a shortage, and the whole world's demand is jacking up our price.
Here is how that works, and what I think happens next.
Here is the easiest way I know to explain it.
If you grow wheat in Idaho, your wheat is not worth what Boise will pay for it. It is worth what the world will pay for it. If buyers overseas are paying three times more this year, the price in Idaho goes up too. The highest bid sets the price for everybody.
Gasoline now works the same way. That is new, and it is the whole story.
Since 1949, America imported more fuel than it sold. We were the customer. When Americans drove less, the price fell, because we were the biggest buyer on earth. That is what happened in 2008.
That is not the country we live in anymore. In 2011 the United States sold more refined fuel to the world than it bought for the first time in 62 years, thanks mostly to fracking, and the gap has grown every year since.
Today the U.S. is the largest exporter of refined fuel in the world.
In April we sent a record 13.6 million barrels a day out of the country, crude and fuel combined.
In June we shipped more gasoline to Mexico than in any month on record.
About one in every five barrels of diesel that crosses an ocean started in an American refinery.
Now look at who is trying to buy our fuel.
The war with Iran has kept a large share of the Persian Gulf's oil off the market since early this year.
Russia used to be the biggest seller of diesel on earth. In July it banned diesel exports, and it is now buying fuel from India and South Korea.
Europe, which got its fuel from all of those places, is paying the equivalent of about $10 to $12 a gallon for diesel.
Germany has cut its fuel tax.
France and Spain are writing checks to drivers.
So here is the mechanism, plainly. It confused me initially, because a gallon of diesel is about $6.50 here and $10 to $12 there, so it looks like the refinery is giving Americans a break. It is not. Most of that gap is their taxes. Strip out the taxes and Europe pays about $6 a gallon for the diesel itself, and so do we.
We are not short of gasoline. The world is short of fuel. And we are now part of the world's market instead of a country with a market of its own.
When gas goes to $5 and stays, it plays out like this. We are just at the start of it.
First, the pull back. People buy less gas, and then less of everything else. Walmart's chief financial officer said on their August earnings call that when fuel gets above $4, "consumers are making trade-offs." Their customers were filling up with less than ten gallons at a time for the first time since 2022. Convenience stores saw pump visits fall ten percent. Sales of things that are not groceries fell six percent.
That was at $4.10. The national average is $4.48 today. Most of the West is over five.
Then, the pass-through. Freight. The fuel surcharge on a UPS or FedEx ground package is now 29 percent, a record. On international air freight it is 47 percent. A trucker recently told the Detroit News he is paying about $955 to fill a 120-gallon tank that used to cost $500. Farm diesel at harvest is $5.45 against $3.02 last fall.
Every one of those costs is on its way to a shelf near you. It takes a few weeks to get there.
Then, the Fed. On September 16 the Federal Reserve raised interest rates for the first time since 2023, and it has penciled in another. It did that because prices are rising and it fears inflation.
Prices are rising in large part because of fuel. So the Fed is fighting a war shortage by making it more expensive to borrow. It is treating the problem like an overheated economy, and it is not one. A higher rate does not put a single barrel back on the market.
It does raise the rate on your credit card, your car loan, and the line a small business runs on.
This week I talked with a homeowner who wants to build a small guest house on his property. He has the equity. His bank quoted him 12% on a home equity line. He dropped the project on the spot. That is what a rate hike does. It does not lower the price of diesel. It cancels a guest house, and the crew that would have built it.
The Fed only controls the short term interest rates. The ten-year Treasury touched five percent on September 16, the first time since 2007, and this week it hit its highest level since 2002. It is about 5.2% as I write this. The 30-year mortgage just shot up past 7.5% in the daily lender surveys.
Put it together and you have three things at once.
My last letter detailed how, in spite of the headlines, job growth was flat over the year, while not producing the raises to absorb this.
This letter is about the fuel tax on everyone. And the Fed just made credit lines more expensive.
A household can usually cover one of those. Two is hard. Three is what people mean when they say they feel it, because it is hitting them at every turn.
Knowing all that, it was still a surprise to me to see consumer sentiment come in at 48, the second-lowest reading in the history of a survey that goes back to the 1950s. The only lower one was this May.
The last two times gas prices surged, prices fell fast. Here is why.
In 2008 gasoline hit $4.11 in July and was $1.61 by Christmas. In 2022 it hit $5.02 in June and was $3.09 by New Year's. Both times the drop was fast.
In 2008 that meant a financial crisis. The economy came to a screeching halt, demand for fuel dropped quickly, so prices fell quickly too.
2022 was the year of the fastest interest rate hikes in forty years, plus the biggest release from the emergency reserve ever, plus refineries with spare capacity coming back online.
Today, those emergency reserves are already at 1982 levels, and the refineries are already running at full capacity. (I'm digging in more on refineries and oil companies in the next letter.)
So the honest answer to "when will fuel prices drop" is this: fuel prices fall when people buy less, and people buy less when they have less. Not just here in America, but globally as well.
That could happen fast. High prices around the world could push local and foreign markets into a recession, dropping demand quickly, with prices following. That is what happened both times before.
Or it could take a while. My hunch is there is so much fear of running out baked into fuel prices that foreign countries will keep buying as much as they can while they can, in fear that they won't be able to later. That keeps prices high longer than the math says they should be.
Either way, eventually high prices cause people to buy less. How long that takes, no one knows in this current situation.
What you can do with that answer is the household math, and it is simple. A two-car family is paying roughly $100 to $130 a month more for gasoline than it did a year ago, before a single grocery or delivery package gets more expensive.
If you are budgeting, budget for that, and for the cost of food, goods, and services to follow.
This is PART 1 of the story, and it is not intended to scare you, but to give you a heads up, because o much of today's news has a spin, an agenda, or is sensationalized to grab your attention.
PART 2 is where all the money from these high fuel prices is going, and the answer surprised me more than any of this. Here is a preview: refineries just had their best quarter since 2022 (when the Russia and Ukraine war started), and the last new oil refinery in America opened almost 50 years ago, in 1977 (that is not a typo). More on that in the next letter, which should land tomorrow.
That's all for today.
Cheers,
Mike T.
###
P.S. If this landed in your inbox from a friend, here is who is writing. My name is Mike Turner. I am an entrepreneur, a father, and a husband, and I am curious about people, history, and how the world works. I write these letters following my own curiosity, sorting actual facts out of the noise, and my only aim is to inform. I am not selling anything, I do not take on clients, and I am not a financial advisor. I invest in my own local market, and I feel compelled to share what I learn along the way. What you get here is research, insight, and my opinion, never a recommendation. If you find it useful, share it, or don't. If you think I am missing something, or have a topic you want covered, reply. I read every one.
Forwarded by a friend? Get the Letter
Manage Which Emails You Get...
https://preview.convertkit-mail4.com/preferences
Every week I write a letter about what I'm seeing in the world and in life, and my thoughts on how it may impact us locally and personally. An honest take, with no spin or agenda.I'm a former ship captain, Coast Guard officer, and 25-year entrepreneur. I started out on the path I thought I was supposed to follow: work hard in school, get the good job, climb the ladder, commute in the suit and tie. Then I proved to myself that I could make it on my own, building work that helped people while giving my family a kind of freedom no salary could, and I never looked back. Raising a family with no safety net of steady income forced me to get creative, to build whatever skill the moment demanded, and to pay close attention to how money, economies, and politics really work, because when there's no net, you can't afford to be blindsided by the next storm. I've failed more times than I can count. The difference is I never stopped looking for a way up the mountain. And somewhere on that climb I learned the truth about the mountain: there's no summit where everything finally gets better. You have to fall in love with the journey as it unfolds, even when it's hard and the future is uncertain. That's the aim underneath everything I do: living well.My goal with these letters is simply to give. Not to sell you anything, not to convince you of anything. Just to share what I'm learning on my journey, and insights that might prove helpful in yours.
U.S. Housing Market is Cracking. How Bad is it?New homes now cost less than existing ones for the first time in 50 years. Here is what that means. Mike Turner | Nov 8, 2026 Writing this one from the patio, with a live soundtrack. Seven charts and two weeks of digging, condensed to one Sunday read. I could have written the scariest housing story you have read all year. The numbers are sitting right there. If I were a news outlet, a podcast host, or a YouTuber who needed your click, here is how...
Most of what keeps our lights on was built by our grandparents.Our power bills are going up. And a way to fix it that is being tested an hour from Boise, Idaho. Mike Turner | Oct 25, 2026 Gas and diesel are still near record highs, and our power bills are going up on top of them. It is obvious to most of us that the wars are driving fuel prices. What surprised me, when I started digging into how America makes and moves its energy, is how little of it we have built in my lifetime. Most of what...
A solution to $5 gas prices: I am calling it the "American Backstop."The easy fixes all fail for the same reason. Here is the deal I would offer instead, and who gets to own it. (Part 3 of 3) Mike Turner | Oct 5, 2026 Is it right that refineries are posting record profits while the rest of us pay $5 a gallon? Should the government do something about it? And what could be done that is fair to the private company and to the American public? Those are the questions readers have been sending me...